It goes without saying that proper screening and hiring processes are your best defense against unwanted turnover. Coming from a perspective that every person has something unique to offer—something that must have been seen during the selection and interview process—there are still many factors that can influence the outcome of an employee-employer relationship. These factors are often responsible for challenges that arise in working relationships, ultimately determining whether an individual is truly a good fit.
Factors Influencing Employee Fit
One of the most common challenges is the exaggeration of experiences and competencies during the hiring process. This can create significant barriers to training and development due to a lack of understanding or capability. Often, candidates assume that the skills required for the job must be fully mastered beforehand, rather than recognizing the potential for learning on the job. When expectations don’t align, it can lead to frustration on both sides.
Another key factor is the true motivation behind taking the role. If a candidate’s primary drive is simply to generate an income without regard to the work itself or its outcomes, the synergy necessary for a strong working relationship will inevitably falter. Engaged employees with a genuine desire to be part of the team and its processes are essential to creating a cohesive, productive environment.
Transparency in short- and long-term goals is also critical. Employers may seek a short-term solution for a role they envision evolving over time, while the employee may be seeking a long-term career path with room to grow and be challenged. Misalignment in these goals can strain the relationship and ultimately lead to separation.
The Importance of Open Communication and Feedback
Given the human element at the heart of every employment relationship, establishing open, honest, timely, and direct feedback channels is vital. It’s not uncommon for the "honeymoon" stage of employment to last for several months, especially in situations where there are significant operational deficiencies. Building this reality into employee evaluations is important because a poor fit may go unnoticed for too long, causing deeper issues that are difficult to untangle.
Strategies for Navigating Fit and Separation
To ensure that both new and tenured employees are well-supported—and to identify potential misalignment early—consider the following actions:
Establish Clear Lines of Communication: Open, two-way communication between employees and leaders or decision-makers is essential. Both parties must feel comfortable expressing their needs, goals, and concerns.
Provide Consistent, Honest Feedback: Regular feedback on work performance should be given with a focus on honesty and directness. The goal is not just to document, but to provide both parties with a realistic view of how the relationship is working.
Set Benchmarks for Formal Dialogue: Create triggers for formalized discussions and performance reviews. These benchmarks should facilitate feedback in both directions, holding the employer accountable as well.
Share Workload Results: When possible, share the outcomes of the team's work—both successes and challenges—with everyone. This encourages a sense of collective ownership and allows the entire business to celebrate or address issues together.
Observe Performance Directly: If leaders receive feedback on an employee’s performance from others, they should make every effort to observe the behavior themselves. Relying solely on secondhand reports can be problematic and may lead to unfair assessments.
Act Timely on Performance Issues: Don’t wait too long to address concerns. Timely intervention can prevent issues from worsening and allows for a more proactive approach to feedback and correction.
Keep Decisions Business-Focused: Always ensure that decisions about an employee’s fit within the company remain focused on business needs, not personal feelings. This maintains professionalism and clarity in all actions taken.
Separating when things are not a good fit is never easy, but when handled with transparency, fairness, and a commitment to honest communication, it can lead to better outcomes for both the individual and the organization. A thoughtful approach can transform even difficult separations into opportunities for growth and reflection, helping the business maintain its integrity and strength.
Comments